9 Most Recommended Italian Restaurants in Manhattan

Manhattan is full of outstanding Italian restaurants. From cozy Italian restaurants in the East Village to upscale Italian restaurants in the Upper East Side, the city offers an array of ambiances to fit your mood. Here are nine of the most recommended Italian restaurants in Manhattan. 

For an exceptional Italian dining experience, look no further than Rezdôra. This restaurant is widely considered to be one of the best Italian eateries in all of Manhattan, and it's easy to see why. The menu features traditional dishes with a modern twist, and the ingredients are sourced from local farms and producers. The result is a meal that is both delicious and nutritious. The ambiance at Rezdôra is also second to none; the dining room is sleek and stylish, and the service is impeccable. Though the restaurant is relatively young, opening in 2019, it has quickly made a name for itself as one of the top Italian restaurants in Manhattan. If you're looking for an Italian restaurant that will exceed your expectations, Rezdôra is an excellent choice.

Emilio's Ballato is a classic Italian restaurant located in the heart of Manhattan. The restaurant has been serving traditional Italian cuisine for over 25 years, and its menu features favorites such as hand-made gnocchi, lasagna, and tiramisu. The dining room is warm and inviting, with dark wood floors, white tablecloths, and yellow walls decorated with old photos. The waitstaff is attentive and knowledgeable, and they are happy to make recommendations based on your preferences. Whether you are looking for a romantic dinner for two or a night out with friends, Emilio's Ballato is sure to please.

The West Village’s Via Carota is one of the most popular Italian restaurants in Manhattan, and it's easy to see why. Opening in 2014, the restaurant has remained a staple of the West Village community ever since. The food is incredible, and the atmosphere is warm and inviting. But what sets Via Carota apart from other Italian restaurants is its subtle yet delectable appetizers and entrees. All of the dishes are made with seasonal produce that is sourced from local farms, and the meat and fish are all sustainably raised. As a result, Via Carota is able to offer its guests an unparalleled dining experience that is both delicious and responsible. The hand-chopped steak, insalata verde, and pasta dishes are top-notch. If you're looking for an unforgettable Italian dining experience, Via Carota is the place to go.

Don Angie is one of the most recommended Italian restaurants in Manhattan. The West Village gem opened in 2017. The restaurant has an elegant atmosphere, with white tablecloths and fresh flowers on every table. The menu features classic Italian dishes with a modern twist, and the portions are generous. The highlight of the menu is the pinwheel lasagna, which is made with fresh pasta and four different kinds of cheese. The service is professional and attentive, and the prices are fair. If you're looking for a romantic dinner for two or a night out with friends, Don Angie is sure to exceed your expectations.

Marea is one of the best Italian restaurants in Midtown Manhattan — known for its creative and delicious dishes. The menu features a variety of seafood, including lobster, scallops, and octopus. The ingredients are top-quality, and the dishes are expertly prepared. The setting is luxurious, and the service is impeccable. Marea is a perfect choice for a special occasion or a romantic evening out. Thanks to its delicious food, beautiful setting, and excellent service, Marea is one of the most popular Italian restaurants in Manhattan.

Carbone is a classic Italian-American restaurant in the heart of Greenwich Village. The menu features traditional dishes with a twist, such as the spicy rigatoni vodka, a pasta entree served in a creamy pink sauce spiked with vodka and chili peppers. The restaurant’s decor is elegant but also cozy, with red leather banquettes and white tablecloths. The service is impeccable, and the wine list is extensive. In short, Carbone is the perfect spot for a special night out. If you're celebrating a special event such as an anniversary or simply looking for a delicious meal, Carbone is a great choice.

If you're looking for a truly exceptional Italian dining experience in Manhattan, look no further than Rubirosa. This chic spot serves up some of the best pizzas in town, courtesy of acclaimed Chef Angelo Romano. But it's not just the pizzas that make Rubirosa worth a visit — the whole menu is full of delicious dishes that are sure to satisfy even the most discerning palate. The sophisticated atmosphere and attentive service complete the experience, making Rubirosa one of the most recommended Italian restaurants in town.

Il Buco is an intimate, yet incredible Italian restaurant in Manhattan’s NoHo neighborhood. Opened in 1994, the family-owned restaurant is a favorite for upscale, yet relaxed Italian dining. Dim lighting, wooden tables, and visible wine racks evoke old Italy. The menu draws inspiration from both Italian and Iberian cuisines, and every ingredient is locally sourced when possible. Owners Donna Leonard and Alberto Avalle have run the restaurant since its inception; Il Buco is a staple of the cobblestone Bond Street in NoHo. 

Epistrophy is one of the most popular Italian restaurants in downtown Manhattan. The restaurant offers a wide variety of classic Italian dishes with a Sardinian twist, and the menu is always changing to reflect the freshest seasonal ingredients. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, and the service is impeccable. For a romantic dinner for two or a lively night out with friends, Epistrophy is sure to please. And if you're a fan of Italian wine, you'll be glad to know that the restaurant has an impressive list of both red and white wines. So next time you're in the mood for some exceptional Italian food with a Sardinian flair, be sure to pay a visit to Epistrophy.

Ready to purchase a home in Manhattan so that you can always enjoy the top Italian restaurants Manhattan has to offer? Contact Rebecca Blacker & Arlene Reed today to explore your options. They are expert real estate agents with your satisfaction as their #1 priority.